If a person is selected as a PARTY ANIMAL at three RGs they are made members of the "PARTY ANIMAL Hall of Fame" and are not eligible to be chosen again. Tiffany Everett became the latest Hall of Fame member in December 2018.
| Cher Burnham - '93 | Mary Jane Tala - '93 | Robert Andrus - '95 |
| Yvonne Porter - '95 | Rochelle Lefarth - '96 | David Plottel - '96 |
| Red Bellamy - '97 | Mary Lee Kemper - '00 | Loretta Olson - '01 |
| Debra Williams - '01 | Niki Foor - '02 | Rob Foor - '03 |
| Linda Hathaway - '03 | Ray O'Connor - '03 | Greg Crawford - '04 |
| Nancy Heller - '05 | Virginia Plottel - '05 | Janet Century - '06 |
| Misty Richmond - '06 | Beth Weiss - '06 | John Massura - '07 |
| Teresa Gregory - '08 | Stormie Kullman - '08 | Anne So - '08 |
| De Freshwater - '09 | Sandy Johnson - '10 | Rachel Nelli - '10 |
| Mike Collins - '11 | George Cooper - '11 | Heidi Macneal - '11 |
| John Neemidge - '11 | Stan Ward - '12 | Neil Caesar - '13 |
| Jan Pfeil Doyle - '13 | Mary Ann Mochan - '13 | Carten Bachmann - 13' |
| Cyndi Kuyper - '14 | Alan Baltis - '14 | Geri Neemidge - '14 |
| Phil Plottel - '14 | Zarya Steele - '15 | Brea Ludwigson - '16 |
| Vera Cartwright - '16 | Tiffany Everett - '18 |